When Life Time's development team priced out a new club prototype, the estimate came back at more than $100 million. At that price, even an ambitious growth strategy starts to look less achievable.
Rather than compromise the member experience, the company went back to the drawing board. The result? A 20% reduction in projected construction costs, twice its original savings target.
It's a telling example of the decisions reshaping retail design today. How do you create compelling destinations while controlling costs? And how do you turn ambitious concepts into stores that work across an entire portfolio?
At RetailSpaces Fall in Palm Springs, Matt Brinza, SVP of Architecture, Design and Engineering at Life Time; Shannon Yeakel, Senior Director of Real Estate Development at DICK'S Sporting Goods; and Rick Neira, VP of VMSD, Space Ops and Creative at Petco, explored these challenges in a conversation moderated by RetailSpaces Producer Zia Durrani.
For Brinza, reducing Life Time's nine-figure prototype wasn't about eliminating amenities. It required questioning the assumptions behind the building itself.
"We went through a process that we call optimization, not value engineering," he explained.
A cross-functional team examined everything from building systems to member-facing technology. Some of the biggest savings came from things members would never notice, including unnecessary redundancies in mechanical, electrical, and plumbing systems.
Connected fitness equipment with built-in heart-rate monitors also offered diminishing value when many members already tracked their workouts through personal wearables.
The team initially targeted 10% savings but achieved 20%. For a company pursuing $1.2 billion in growth that year, the implications were substantial.
With capital investments being more carefully evaluated, retailers are also rethinking how much to invest in existing locations.
At Life Time, Brinza is advocating for a larger remodel program, challenging the assumption that growth investments should primarily fund new clubs.
"A remodel can also be a growth mechanism," he argued.
Early performance metrics suggest meaningful potential in existing locations. The challenge is renovating without disrupting the routines that keep members coming back. Once those habits disappear, rebuilding them becomes considerably harder.
DICK'S faces a similar calculation, evaluating whether to remodel successful stores or relocate into larger House of Sport formats.
Those approximately 120,000-square-foot destinations have also strengthened the retailer's position with landlords.
"We're almost like a department store," Yeakel explained, pointing to the substantial traffic DICK'S generates for surrounding retail properties.
While DICK'S experiments with massive experiential destinations, Petco faces the opposite challenge: fitting merchandise, grooming, veterinary care, and community events into stores typically measuring 10,000 to 15,000 square feet.
"I gotta get all that into a little sardine can," Neira joked.
Rather than eliminating experiences, Petco is rethinking how they fit together.
Veterinary and grooming services have moved closer to store entrances, making them easier to access. Shared check-in areas free up valuable space, while flexible layouts accommodate adoption events and other community activities.
This flexibility matters as desirable retail real estate becomes more competitive. Petco increasingly encounters unconventional spaces, requiring additional time to test layouts and validate customer flow.
A store plan that once took a week or two to evaluate can now take two or three. "You may draw 150 projects to land 50," Neira explained.
Still, Neira emphasized that functionality should take priority over visual appeal. A beautiful store means little if employees struggle to operate it or customers find it difficult to navigate.
Across all three brands, the conversation returned to a fundamental question: What makes a physical destination worth visiting?
For Life Time, the focus has shifted from adding amenities to fostering engagement, relationships, and the social experiences that turn occasional visits into lasting habits.
Brinza argued that retailers can learn from hospitality by considering the entire customer journey. Natural light, acoustics, cleanliness, and even how employees greet members influence whether people feel comfortable spending time in a space.
DICK'S is applying that thinking through family-oriented activities that encourage shoppers to interact with products. At Petco, it might be a welcoming environment where employees know a customer's pet by name.
Even the strongest store concept is only as good as a retailer's ability to bring it to market.
Asked what was slowing development projects, all three panelists pointed to the same obstacle: permitting.
Brinza described a project that had been navigating a state health department's review process for nearly a year. Despite experimenting with permitting technology, his team found that some of the best results still come from building relationships with reviewers.
"When you pick up the phone and call them, they know who you are," he explained.
The most revealing comment came from Neira, who acknowledged something designers don't always like to admit: a beautiful store can still be a bad store.
"If it's too pretty, but it doesn't function," he warned, customers "may not come back."
That observation captures the challenge facing retail development teams. The real measure of success isn't how impressive a store looks on opening day, but whether the experience continues to bring customers back.
As DICK'S, Petco, and Life Time demonstrate, the future of retail design may be shaped less by how much retailers build than by how intelligently they use what they have.